what technique does wiesel use to build tension on the approach to the auschwitz crematoriums?
Where Is Love?
If his is indeed an accurate portrayal of a group of Jews who survived a few extra weeks by doing the bidding of the Nazi pigs who run the extermination camps, God help usa! This is ane of the bleakest things I have ever seen. We, of course, have to ask the simple question, "What is life worth?" If the respond is everything, then nosotros tin can empathize why these poor souls did what they did. In every portrayal of these camps, we run across how powerless the inmates are. They are confront daily with pistols and machine guns. They are arbitrarily shot in the caput for crying, or just continuing in the wrong place. They are the victims. What most the Germans? How can a human existence do this to some other and take pleasure in it? I know how naive that question is, but it is certainly at the central cadre of everything. The closing scene is and then hopeless and so gripping. There are nearly surrealistic moments, almost like those in silent films where a face up is made to stand for a m words. I dubiety I could watch this again. I also don't know that there is some other holocaust flick that tin affect 1 any more than this.
1 out of 1 institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A magnificent film about Auschwitz's Sonderkommandos, existence splendidly played
An eerie and downbeat motion picture with a grouping of unfortunate characters, nigh of them members of a Sonderkommando : David Arquette, Daniel Benzali, Steven Buscemi, among others . Along with a Jew medico : Allan Corduner and doctor Mengele himself . And a brutal Nazi sergeant : Harvey Keitel. Things go wrong when they notice and hibernate a 14-year-former girl and get involved themselves into the grey zone. The story you haven't seen!.
A terrific and extraordinary movie dealing with the inferno of the camps of death located in Auschwitz . Here we watch the astonishing work of the Sonderkommandos past executing the deadly and forced assignments. It contains a fabulous cast giving vigorous performances, outstanding Allan Cordunier as the Jew doctor who must decide a circuitous situation , Harvey Keitel equally a ruthless Nazi and David Arquette whose fury outbursts at the gas chamber against a distressed condemned past means of a sudden explosion of grisly violence . And 2 female prisoners Natasha Lyonne and Mira Sorvino. The motion flick was competently directed past Tim Blake Nelson. He is a notorious secondary who has written, produced and directed a few films.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sonderkommandos
Warning: Spoilers
A staggeringly provocative story based on true events. During World War Two, Hitler placed hundreds of thousands of Jewish prisoners in concentration camps to be gassed, excinerated and buried; all kept secret from the German citizens and the world. The Nazis chose Special Squads from these prisoners to be Sonderkommandos; given a few more months of life in substitution for their help in exterminating young man Jews. Personal and moral dilemma aside cause soft hearts to become dark and hard. One such grouping of Sonderkommandos painstakingly hoard enough weaponry for an organized revolt. Equally this uprising looms closer a young girl is found alive...surviving a gas chamber. At present can personal redemption exist attained by helping this daughter live a little longer and a adventure to escape? Needless to say many endured torture merely to let other prisoners a few more hours of life. A peak-notch ensemble features: Steve Buscemi, Harvey Keitel, Mira Sorvino, Allan Corduner, David Arquette, Henry Stram, David Chandler, Velizar Biney and Kamelia Grigorova.
0 out of one plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Nighttime exploration of human being's inhumanity to human being...
Despite all the realism depicted in THE Greyness ZONE amid the actual twenty-four hour period to day operations of a Nazi prison camp, there's a certain stage quality in the dialog that serves as a reminder that you're watching the screen version of a stage play and not what should seem more like a truthful life documentary. That's the fault of the script taken from David Mamet's play and other heart-witness sources--just the acting is excellent.
And yet, it does manage to convey but how those prison camps used other prisoners to operate the gas chambers, to carry out the deed with simulated promises--"Just be sure to remember where you claw the clothes so you can pick upward your holding when yous leave"--and the arduous jobs of loading trucks with expressionless bodies and depositing them on chutes that go directly into a blazing furnace. Amid all this, various stories are entwined involving the petty quarrels amid the men assigned to these tasks so they could prolong their own lives for at least four months of assured survival.
The story involving a girl who does not die during the xx-infinitesimal gassing and is and then revived and how the men argue over how to protect her from further harm, is intense and touching in that information technology shows the humanity that is still in their souls. Her story and how information technology ends is one of the film'south most memorable and touching elements.
This is more of an in depth wait at "the concluding solution" than any other recent films dealing with the extermination of Jews has e'er been, with the exception of SCHINDLER'S LIST and THE PIANIST in which the accent was more on the triumph of the homo spirit and a much broader view of the war itself in epic manner.
This is a darker, intimate look at the actual operation of the camps as experienced by a scattering of prisoners--the brutality, the torture, and raises the question: how far would you go to survive? It also shows how non all the Jews were as passive about their fate every bit some accept claimed, often opposing the Nazi officers and paying for information technology with their lives.
In the hands of a greater managing director, it might take been an even more than impressive picture than it is, and then that I'1000 unable to place it in the same class with the two films mentioned above. The bandage is uniformly expert, but HARVEY KEITEL is outstanding as an SS Commander keeping strict tabs on the army camp's hard-working dr..
In its own way, it's just equally important. Young students of history would exist well advised to view this one for a better agreement of how "the final solution" was supposed to occur and the methods used to carry out an enormous project known as "the holocaust".
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Non-parallel in depicting the truthful horrors of The Holocaust
THE Grey ZONE (2002) **** David Arquette, Harvey Keitel, Mira Sorvino, Natasha Lyonne, Daniel Benzali, Steve Buscemi, Allan Corduner, David Chandler. Director Tim Blake Nelson (who adapted his play of the same name) paints a vivid, bleak, depressing and ultimately powerful moving picture of The Holocaust focusing on the Sonderkommando, Jews who were enlisted to work the crematoria of Auschwitz and other death camps, in hopes of surviving a trivial longer in the ongoing nightmare of the Nazi authorities during WWII. A vastly talented cast does an adept job conveying the horror, pain, suffering and most significantly the soul of what was experienced in both good and evil with the fine line blurring in the title'south suggestion while Nelson also conveys the engulfing surroundings shared by both. Aquette gives the performance of his career in a memorable dramatic plow every bit a savagely conflicted immature man facing impossible odds. A very important pic that needs to be seen and dispel those severely misinformed that The Holocaust was a farce. One of the year's best.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
How far will people go to survive?
Alarm: Spoilers
The Grey Zone explores well-covered territory from a unique bending: that of the Jewish prisoners who prolonged their lives by four months by becoming members of a unit used to herd their fellow prisoners into the gas chambers. Inevitably, such a discipline matter raises the question of to what lengths the viewer would go in order to stay alive, and the toll to the people who found themselves capable of colluding with their captors. When ane new inflow to Auschwitz, ferried straight from the train to the shower'southward irresolute room, loudly challenges Hoffman (David Arquette) over his and his friend's informal instructions to remember the number of the hook on which they hang their dress so that they tin find them afterward the shower, Hoffman beats him to a bloody pulp – as if for forcing him to confront what he is doing to his people. Despite this, the performances are subdued for the nigh part, the prisoner'south attitudes to their situation almost matter-of-fact. Given fine nutrient and alcohol in payment for their work, they alive in ivory towers that accept been stained by man ashes.
The survival of a young girl afterward showering in the Nazi's deadly gas only as the men are preparing to stage their revolt triggers an emotional crisis amongst the members of the unit of measurement, with some insisting she be killed for their protection and others demanding she exist allowed to alive. They face a dilemma that is mirrored by those of the High german soldiers who manufactory around the girl uncertainly after the protesters have all been killed. At that place is a line beyond which fifty-fifty those who accept grown almost inhumanly inured to killing volition hesitate to step. The daughter, alone and defenceless, dissimilar the masses herded into the showers, forces them to put a confront to their victims and ejects them from their oddly cocooned being.
The film is an adaptation of a stage play, apparently, and this fact is evident in the dialogue, which sometimes seems unreal, as if the speakers are somehow detached from the emotions they are supposed to be feeling. This may be deliberate, another example of the tamping downwardly of their true emotions, but its sometimes distracting. Despite this, the performances are good, especially that of Harvey Keitel who seems to grow into the part of the German officeholder who knows he has lost touch with everything that made him human.
2 out of 2 institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Numbing horror
=G= v June 2003
"The Gray Zone" transports the audience to the epicenter of evil during WWII'due south terminal solution to the Jewish question. The moving-picture show deals with a grouping of doomed Jewish Auschwitz Pw'southward who do the death camp'south dirty piece of work, herding unsuspecting Jews into the showers, carrying cadavers to the crematorium, harvesting the dead for gold dentalwork, etc. The film takes on a challenging subject with countless moral issues to ponder equally it scrutinizes the nuts and bolts of mass extermination. All the same, information technology doesn't quite mensurate up to the strong field of study with its theatrical presentation, clipped dialogue, time wasting filler, staginess, poor graphic symbol depth, disruptive language and dialect bug, and a rather contrived monologue at the end. Nevertheless, the films treats the bailiwick with dignity, does non exploit or sensationalize, and recreates enough of the horror to impart a sense of what it must take been like giving it docudramatic value. Worth a look for anyone interested in the holocaust. (B)
iii out of four found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Fine Study Of Collaboration, But ...
I wasn't at all familiar with this movie, but because of an abiding interest in the history of the Third Reich and the Holocaust, I decided to rent information technology. The true story was one that I wasn't familiar with: the rebellion of a group of Jews at a Nazi concentration campsite. The jacket of the DVD placed the focus of the movie on the rebellion, merely that was a bit misleading. The bulk of the story had much more to do with the mindset of collaboration than with the rebellion, which really received very little focus, until the end of the movie.
In this film, nosotros learn most the "Sonderkommandos" - groups of Jews who helped the Nazis maintain order at the concentration camps in commutation for a few extra privileges and a few extra months of life. The look at the mindset of collaboration was fascinating. The sonderkommandos are - understandably - looked downwardly on by the rest of the Jews; the sonderkommandos themselves have some definite moral qualms most their piece of work and - in spite of their own collaboration with the Nazis - they are definitely antagonistic toward Dr. Nyiszli (Allan Corduner), a Jewish doctor who gets even more than privileges by co-operating in Nazi medical experiments on some of the captives. They're Jews who merely don't fit in with the victims of the Holocaust (although they, too, volition become its victims), and however, even though they help the Nazis, they evidently don't fit in to that circle, either. Their existence was lived in a true "greyness zone," in other words. This is a troubling story in many ways (every bit surely whatever flick about the Holocaust should be!) with some scenes being quite graphic.
And still, somehow the movie didn't keep me glued to the screen. Information technology was interesting, but actually non more that, and I had hoped to learn more about the rebellion itself, which was passed over rather quickly I thought. For those interested in the subject, it'south worth watching, simply certainly non a masterpiece.
6/10
21 out of 38 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Decease Zone
Tim Blake Nelson'due south brave 'The Grey Zone' tells the story of a group of Sonderkommandos, the Jewish workers who were selected to get together the Jewish 'prisoners'to the gas chambers and so dispose of their bodies past burning them. The motion picture is vicious in its portrayal and inappreciably leaves anything to the imagination. It also raises the question of survival. 'The Gray Zone' shows what happened to those who have fought, those who have submitted and surrendered, those who have refused to surrender and those who have accepted their fate. All of them ultimately experienced the same fate. This is no picture with an uplifting catastrophe or a message of hope. It is unsympathetic to the viewer. As managing director and writer, Tim Blake Nelson does a fine job by telling the story and fleshing out the characters. The editing is well done. The execution is slightly on the poorer side. It gives the feel of a TV movie. In the acting department information technology is Harvey Keitel and Mira Sorvino who stand out. Keitel is well acquainted with negative roles and thus information technology is no surprise that he pulls off the part of the Nazi officeholder. Sorvino has a smaller part simply she displays Dina's anguish, courage and despair with skill. David Arquette is better than his usual. 'The Gray Zone' is a worth seeing because it depicts some other side of the Holocaust with a brutally honest treatment and it is thought provoking because while it is easier for some to estimate equally an outsider, information technology raises the question of what one, what you lot, would have done had yous been in the same shoes, knowing that you were going to die no matter what.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Haunting experience
Greetings from Lithuania.
"The Gray Zone" (2011) is a agonizing, a must lookout pic to learn and remember. The things that are portrayed in this picture are not the one time who anyone would lime to retrieve, merely hey happened, and they must exist witnessed to empathise that true nature of humankind is sometimes unforgiven.
This is very well made movie, not gore in images, but brutal in showing reality, that you tin can't but simply turn abroad from. This is not "Schindler'south List", and yet information technology contains stuff, that you won't even read in books, or see in movies.
Overall, eight/x for a portrayal of human being depression key, information technology's unforgettable when you lot will encounter it, not for sensitive soul viewer.
0 out of 0 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Honest just Flawed
"If you understand what happened in the camps, you lot take a much amend agreement of what nosotros're all most every bit human beings" -- Tim Blake Nelson
The Grey Zone is the space between black and white, where everything is relative and there are no moral certainties. In the motion picture, The Grey Zone by Tim Blake Nelson, it represents the ambiguous space between the selfish desire to alive and the selfless sacrifice for others. Nelson explores the moral dilemma of a group of Hungarian Jews known as the Sonderkommandos who knowingly collaborated with the Germans at Birkenau to secure preferential treatment for themselves. This included access to books, booze, cigarettes, amend food, the valuables of the "cargo", and iv additional months to alive.
I duty of the Sonderkommando was leading fellow Jews into the gas chambers while telling them they were going to take a shower. Another was to empty the gas chambers of dead bodies and feed the dead into the ovens. According to Nelson, `The fact is that atmospheric condition in the camps, and particularly in the Sonderkommandos, brought out shameful qualities in men, the most benign of which were mistrust, greed, xenophobia and self-hatred.' The issues the film raises are troublesome, only when faced with the ultimate moral choice, no one really knows how they would act.
All of the characters are fictional except for Dr. Miklos Nyiszli (Allan Corduner) who assisted the notorious Joseph Mengele in his medical experiments on Jews. His book, "Auschwitz: A Doc's Eyewitness Account," was a source for the film, as was Primo Levi's essay "The Drowned and the Saved," about Jews who were forced to become part of the Nazis. The motion picture shows the uncertainty of the Sonderkommandos in dealing with a xv-yr quondam Hungarian girl (Kamelia Grigorova) who miraculously survives the gas chambers. Some want to salve her equally a terminal symbolic human activity; others feel her presence is a hindrance to their plans to destroy the crematoriums and escape. Though the revolt is only partially successful, this incident remains as the only known uprising that took place in the concentration camps.
The Grayness Zone is an honest work but ane that suffers from heavy-handed direction and stilted dialogue. The film is based on Nelson'south phase play from 1996 and the dialogue ofttimes sounds like a rehearsal for a college drama production. The talky screenplay and questionable acting take abroad from the power of the events being depicted. Actors David Arquette and Steve Buscemi look, feel, and speak similar good for you well-fed Americans, not emaciated Hungarian Jews. Harvey Keitel is powerful as usual just his fake High german accent is often giddy. I also found the film to exist unnecessarily graphic in its depiction of women being tortured, prisoners being executed en masse, and old men beingness clubbed to death. The horrors of the holocaust are so incomprehensible that they can only be grasped through proposition, not cinematic hammer blows.
There is an of import story to be told here, but The Grayness Zone ends up as standard Hollywood fare: large-name stars, atrocious accents, and gory violence. In Nelson'south hands, the story that should be gut wrenching becomes an uninvolving spectacle. Fifty-fifty the achingly beautiful Brahms' Alto Rhapsody sung by the immortal contralto Kathleen Ferrier cannot save it.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An Upbeat Little Flick
The Grey Zone furnishes soul and significance for an episode that's lilliputian more than a postscript in history books, the story of the Jewish piece of work units in the Auschwitz concentration military camp. These prisoners were made to assist the camp'due south guards in shepherding their victims to the gas chambers, and so disposing of their bodies in the ovens. Nelson attempts to utilize the past to remind us of the frail vagueness of our own principles, that near of us will never have to know what nosotros might accept the capacity for in detail weather.
And nevertheless Nelson'due south dialogue is like a horse race. Information technology sounds like American slang and divulges its theatrical roots, which works against the potent interim and the intrinsic impact of the subject matter. His screenplay needs to prove more of the catch-22, instead of have his characters put on hostile debates about it. No doubt in that location is much tension created through all the tug of war, but characters are as well graceful and fluent while speaking under pressure and in conflict. I don't experience anyone's true nature comes through in their words, except perhaps Harvey Keitel's surprisingly condign SS officer. You can virtually hear the components of his principled device stirring as characters rap their adages and aphorisms. There's an afflicted purpleness to everything. Sometimes it works and sometimes shrieks of pretension. Nelson takes an emotionally inconceivable situation and comes close to sterilizing it with cocky-conscious technique. Simply ultimately, these are defects that, ironically, make fodder for subsequent discourse.
Nelson, an actor himself, knows experientially how to stimulate and inspire his cast, which is comprised of other strong performances than only Keitel'southward. Needless to say he must also know how to make an player seem not to act, how to put him or her at their ease, bring them to that land of relaxation where their creative faculties are released. I call back for every time that's washed successfully hither, there are just as many instances where nosotros see through the baroque artifice.
Whether its sense of style seems to trivialize the authenticity of its situations, that'due south not to say information technology aims for the heart and misses. There are nevertheless many extraordinarily bleak and, most significantly, unflinchingly emotional scenes and moments that it'south out of the question that you'd not exist moved by the film. The fierce rebellion, played not for hero worship merely with somber fatalism, using pocket-size primal tonality in its score. If this story must be told and retold, and to be sure information technology must, so The Grey Zone is to be praised for discovering a new approach. The film's feeling for images gives it a grave intensity, but it'south thrust by the acting, self-witting or not. And non similar many mainstream Holocaust films, even bang-up, monumental ones, The Gray Zone is actually frank plenty to renounce the prospect of hopefulness in Auschwitz. Or the world.
The film sneers at how we, most of us, more than than we'd like to know, feel we can generalize about groups of people, races, nations, ethnic and religious groups, how in the bleakest of examples of this shameful human weakness gone to the extreme, it is all cocky-fulfilling prophecy. When y'all take away the rights of people, when y'all dehumanize them, they will of course work as corruptly and extremely every bit you to survive your oppression. I day sit down and brand a list of groups of people in any or all countries, not least of which ours, that can be equated to this, and you may run into a less distilled, less explicit holocaust that may or may not terminate.
ane out of three constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Brilliant holocaust movie
This is a worthy successor to Schindler'south List, though far darker. The sense of totalitarianism is palatable, tragic. Hither is an intense examination of homo behaviour when all the participants, even the Germans, are across fatalism, and it is divertingly intelligent. The writers must have spend ages making conversations on betoken, and seemingly absolutely accurate. In that regard there are many levels. There is blowing, what can inmates get abroad with saying to their superiors, and at what cost, what risk? There is conflict, and there is guilt and degrees of guilt. Each private'south sense and level of guilt and consequent priority causes constant friction with those around him or her. This goes direct to the middle of what it ways to be a good and decent homo. The tension throughout has a horror dimension, the soundscape being almost entirely industrial, truly eerie. The realism of the scenes is a vision of hell. It's non depressing, the characters rise with massive cynicism above simple surrender. I doubtable there is classic irony here as well. The importance of this movie cannot be understated, specially as it is a very good movie from the bespeak of view of movie criteria, let alone the gravity of the subject cloth. For me, this is Great Art, and brave filmmaking.
one out of two found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The most powerful flick concerning the Holocaust.
A actually gripping drama, well acted and with some horrific, chilling scenes. I think 'The Gray Zone' is the all-time of, the most horrid aspect (the extermination of Jews) of W.West.2. Some of the best American actors, such as Buscemi and Keitel (although speaking in English) are completely believable. The whole key of the moving picture is obviously very tragic but concerns a real life revolt that knocked out ii of the crematorium in Ausctwitz. The instigators became heroes, in what was for most, a lost cause.
i out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Harrowing film with plenty of questions
Warning: Spoilers
If you have seen enough of Holocaust films like I take then y'all tin expect the usual bleakness and horrors but this motion picture asks its viewers what they would exercise if they were in the aforementioned predicament and before you lot brand a jerky response y'all should rethink your answer. Story is nearly the true story of a defection at the Auschwitz Ii-Birkenau where many of the ovens were destroyed that would end upwardly saving lives. Within these camps the Nazi's had Sonderkommandos who were Jews that would help gas other Jews in exchange for amend living weather condition and food and liquor. David Arquette is Hoffman and he and others are in charge of the Sonderkommandos and they must live with the fact that they aid with the murder of countless other Jews. Physician Miklos Nyiszli (Allan Corduner) is also a Jew but he is liked by Josef Mengele and in order to keep his family alive he must perform experiments on the prisoners and he is under the watchful eye of an alcoholic Nazi Officer SS-Oberscharfuhrer Eric Muhsfeldt (Harvey Keitel) and he hears rumors that an insurgence is going to occur.
*****SPOILER Warning*****
In the woman'south camp some of the female prisoners take taken some gunpowder and subconscious information technology only the Nazi'south observe information technology and they starting time to torture Dina (Mira Sorvino) and Rosa (Natasha Lyonne). Subsequently gassing many Jews Hoffman discovers a young girl (Kamelia Grigorova) that has survived and he sneaks her into Dr. Nyiszli's office where she is revived and they determine to try and hide her.
This flick was directed past Tim Blake Nelson and its based on his play and also the book about the real Dr. Nyiszli who survived the war and Nelson had this filmed in buildings that were peculiarly designed to be just like the real Auschwitz buildings. I was hesitant to come across another holocaust film but after watching this I came away thinking about two things. The first are the questions that this moving-picture show asks its viewers, What would I do in that state of affairs? Information technology would exist so easy to say that I would just allow myself to be executed but for many this wouldn't be that simple. Also, if you stay around you tin can help others by being involved in an uprising that will save many. These are difficult questions and I commend Nelson for also reminding everyone that the Jews did everything they could to terminate what was going on. They did manage to destroy many ovens and the end consequence was many lives being saved. The second matter that I was reminded of is that David Arquette is a very good actor that doesn't get enough chances to show information technology. He'south shown good performances in small roles such equally "Ravenous" simply he always has to appear in commonly impaired comedies to make a living. I hope future filmmakers remember him when they bandage their next moving picture. The big flaw of this picture show is the casting of American actors as either Germans or Hungarians and they don't even speak with accents. Keitel is the but one that speaks with one and its not all that convincing. If you tin get over that and however sit through a film that you lot know is going to exist bleak and depressing than you might appreciate what Nelson is trying to exercise. I did and I think this is a film that shows an event that everyone should be aware of.
ii out of three establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
I do not give this the reverence most others are according it
In fact, I found nearly of it unintelligible, the script was laughable and the horrific scenes seemed costless. This was meant to be an important exam of the jews who had to work to survive, and what this work entailed, in the death camps. But I found the characters shallow in the extreme, I could not become emotionally involved with any of them - well plenty to care when they were "terminated" in some way. I found the dialogue hokey in the extreme, a lot of repetitive lines and long silences that seemed so stagey, I mean the Nazis and the Jews communicated in this atrocious Hogan'southward Heroes' English but with meaningful silences sprinkled throughout? I felt like I was missing something and left the theatre forth with the others who were there, simply baffled. The horror did not get to us, none of the characters did and even the sound of the movie was gibberish at times. It seemed to be trying to exist of import. I remember Schindler'south List which had the audience sitting in stunned silence until the credits had long since ceased to scroll. Here, nosotros were all anxious to get out into the clean air and shake off that hokey dust. 3 out of ten.
seven out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stark and Unflinching!
Tim Blake Nelson takes his stage play--an adaptation of a book by Miklos Nyiszki--to the large screen,and what a story information technology is!
An unthinkable,unconscionable deal has been worked out between a certain grouping of Nazi death army camp inmates and their captors: in order to avoid the ovens(in all likelihood,only temporarily),these inmates would employ their talents(among them,musical) to placate and ease forth the funneling of other Jews and "undesirables" into the death chambers. A strong bandage and an fifty-fifty stronger screenplay/script is augmented by very intelligent cinematography. Particularly good turns by David Arquette,Steve Buscemi,Daniel Benzali and Mira Sorvino every bit the inmates,all desperate,all convinced of what they have to do to survive and in Arquette'southward character's case,non even certain if it is fifty-fifty worth it.
It would be tempting to slam "Schindler'southward List" after seeing this,just I won't. SL is meant as an epic,a tribute,a story of the upside of surviving through the most dense of human being tragedy,whereas GZ is a decidedly darker exploration of what happens to people in the same situation but are pushed into much less noble,much more than selfish and desperate devices. Both are stiff examples of the genre,but where GZ triumphs is that that it explores the most damning actions through the consciences of people faced with decisions that nobody should have to make. Information technology is an unflinching portrait of a dark affiliate in human history,rife with detail and completely defective of lecturing. THis film is for anyone who wants to see an unvarnished and stark portrayal of the homo condition brought to its lowest denominator. A must-see for college classrooms and Holocaust museums anywhere!
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A must run across
The true story of a Jewish uprising in Auschwitz, Poland during the World War Two is the setting for Tim Blake Nelson'southward gripping and relentless new movie The Grey Zone.
David Arquette (Eight Legged Freaks), Daniel Benzali (Murder One) and David Chandler 4 play Smoothen Jews who work for the Germans by calming others earlier entering the gas chamber and by disposing of their remains through one of the iii crematoriums on campus. In exchange for their efforts, the SS - Oberscharfuhrer Eric Muhsfeldt, played by Harvey Kietel (The Bad Luitenant), lets them take luxuries unheard of in prison camps like wine and oysters.
With the help of Natasha Lyonne (American Pie) and Mira Sorvino (The Replacement Killers) who smuggle explosives to the men in the wearing apparel of expressionless women, the men brainstorm to plan the destruction of the crematorium even knowing it volition result in their own death.
When guns and weapons are nerveless by one of the Hungarian lead crematoriums , Steve Buscemi (Fargo) tries to convince the group that escape should exist their objective and not the destruction of the military camp.
All this planning leads to the insurgence that occurred i afternoon and resulted in the destruction of two crematoriums and the death of all those participating in the insurgence.
Along the mode, there are a few sub-plots. All interesting in their entirety. The women are tortured to reveal where the explosives are destined once the Germans discover it in the men's quarters. A kid is establish alive in the gas chamber and the men have the troubling decision to turn her over for a quick death or to effort and hide her from their captors and somewhen smuggle her into one of the women's camps. And a doctor struggles with his decision to aide in the High german's medical experiments in return for the prophylactic of his wife and girl.
Tim Blake Nelson, who both wrote and directed the picture, manages to maintain a dark and gruesome existence of the camp and leaves the viewer wondering what any of us would do to extend our ain lives. My only complaint would be with the writing. The conversations between the Germans and the Jews seem forced, which we tin can believe, however, the same 'my line is over – your line now begins' continues with the internal conversations among the prisoners and it left a cardboard sense of taste in my mouth.
That said, The Greyness Zone is an incredible achievement. Dissimilar Polanski'south 'The Pianist' or Spielberg'south 'Schindler'due south Listing', there are no happy endings in The Grey Zone. Each graphic symbol has to ask him or herself how far would they get for the cause and what would they exist willing to do to their own people to survive another day. It is a pic that volition haunt yous and reveals the pure evil of the death camps in World War Ii. A high recommendation.
ane out of 2 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Can y'all meet yourself in this ethical dilemma?
Having long since ashcanned organized faith for the ethical content of movies, I strongly recommend this one and "Out of the Ashes" for something other than the ordinary Holocaust movies.
You run into these Jewish prisoners pushing the carts holding the bodies of their fellow Jewish prisoners into the furnaces. In one instance, a man is pushing the cart belongings the bodies of his wife and three children. When I afterwards, a staunch capital punishment foe, saw them pushing a live Nazi soldier into the furnace, I was happy........shows you lot the effect of the movie. I went instantly from 'Forgive 70 times vii" to "An center for an center, tooth for a tooth." Then thin is the patina of civilization.
The most heroic human activity I saw here, which reminded me of Jean Moulin's attempt at suicide so that he wouldn't divulge secrets of the French Resistance, was the female prisoner impaling herself on the electric wires of Auschwitz. She had stood and watched every bit the Nazi officer executes ane after the other of her swain female prisoners. One notation that stands out is concrete...the arching shiny steel fence-posts expect much like some of the statuary I've seen elsewhere, possibly meant to evoke memories of those inhuman extermination camps. Terminal night I saw the map of the 'work camps' and the 'extermination camps'...I didn't realize how many of them in that location were.
Some other reason this moving-picture show is good for a discussion grouping is that it somewhat contradicts the idea that 'The Jews went submissively to the ovens." To watch the efforts made to make bombs within those prisons and the continual arguing amidst the prisoners as they attempt to come up with a way to liberation is wonderfully enlightening. Nil is allowed to be 'like shooting fish in a barrel', not fifty-fifty the uniting of these prisoners for a common cause....to save their lives.
Equally I watched the Nazis, and thought about the dehumanizing of the enemy du jour, that has to happen for our good children to kill others, I wondered, "Take there been any memoirs written past Nazi soldiers in those camps, any that would give us some insight into how they turned into murderous barbarians?" Although this film was non given high marks because of it's stylized format, I plant that this artifice assist me to take in what ..if done realistically...would have been as well much to bear.
0 out of 0 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
THE GREY ZONE (DIDIER BECU)
I don't desire to ridiculize things simply how it is possible to brand a dull movie nigh one of the nearly horrible histories of humankind (the concentration camps and then especially the residence where Dr. Mengele was working) is beyond me. At that place was only no story in it, there was only no emotion in this movie, I had to struggle to exist kept awake, and I had no idea what an actor similar Harvey Keitel was doing in such an awful picture. Forget it. I never liked information technology when the Holocaust was used for a Hollywood wet dream but making a talentless televisionmovie isn't that dandy as well.You lot'd ameliorate watch the famous TVseries "Holocaust" instead. There are sure some interesting things left to tell, "The pianist" from Polanski might exist the best example but this one only didn't work.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A TRUE STORY THAT MUST NEVER BE FORGOTTEN!
This true story near the holocaust is riveting and once more shows the virtually evil of evil. The Germans, Nazi's WWII. The performances by all are only terrific in this true story virtually people in the death camps that were forced to do the unthinkable, the unimaginable to survive merely a few extra months. David Arquette is wonderful and Harvey Keitel is his usual fabulous self equally the Nazi atomic number 82 guard. A motion-picture show that must exist seen and remembered forever, so that it never ever happens over again to anyone, anywhere on earth.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dull and poorly acted
Contrary to public opinion, simply making a film about the Holocaust does not guarantee that y'all will have a cracking movie. Case in point, the Grey Zone. This was shoddy at all-time. It utilized the marginal talents of many boob tube actors and one tired Harvey Keitel. It moves at a snail's step and eyes strain equally we listen to these American actors attempt European accents. Moreover, it is supposed to show the bravery of these concentration army camp inmates, withal the finish shows one of the most cowardly displays I accept always seen. Instead of showing a existent uprising, nosotros run into but why the Nazis were able to pull off this dandy tragedy. However, my main criticisms deal with less than inspired acting and a dull story.
12 out of nineteen institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The all-time moving picture I've seen in years
THE GREY ZONE **** Not only is "The Greyness Zone" the best movie of 2002 so far, it's the best movie I've seen in the last few years, menstruum. A masterpiece (and I don't just throw that word effectually) of utterly devastating emotional power, the effect of this film on me was then farthermost that I couldn't move when it was over, and once I could, I shuffled to my car in a daze. It'southward a Holocaust moving picture that tells the true story of Auschwitz'south Sonderkommandos, Jews who were given things like clean sheets, good food, and a few extra months to live in exchange for helping the Nazis exterminate other Jews. The moral question this raises is obvious. What would you do in order to extend your life in this kind of situation, even if only for a curt time? Would the guilt be worth it, if your extended time meant y'all survived until the camp was liberated? The Sonderkommandos have been collecting guns and explosives for a long time in preparation for an armed revolt sometime shortly. Then, while they are cleaning out the piles of bodies from a gas sleeping accommodation, they discover a footling girl (Kamelia Gigorova) who survived the gas. Saving her single life volition complicate and jeopardize the defection, which could salvage many. What should be done in this state of affairs? Though they are fascinating, "The Grayness Zone" is more than just a succession of complex moral dilemmas. It's the about intense and powerful Holocaust film ever made (yes, even more than so than "Schindler's List").
The cast, which includes David Arquette, Harvey Keitel, Mira Sorvino, Steve Buscemi, Allan Corduner and Daniel Benzali, are all unforgettable in their roles. Arquette, in detail, thoroughly erases any doubts about his acting abilities. I don't care how many "Ready To Rumble"'due south or "Come across Spot Run"'s he does from here on; he's paid his dues, as far equally I'k concerned.
Brutal and uncompromising realism, great performances, and some of the about powerful moments on film I've ever seen combine to make ane spectacular movie. It's tough to watch and yous volition feel empty and raw when it's over, but it's an of import moving-picture show and one you will never forget.
1 out of 2 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A trivial more life is no excuse for shameful acts....
An incredibly excruciating pic that's real tough to watch... specially with the knowledge that it's based on factual historical events – very probable from Dr. Miklos Nyiszli'due south eye-witness accounts of the Auschwitz's twelfth Sonderkommando at Birkenau, Poland. Swell bandage of actors, with very credible performances. I felt I was there, watching and waiting for each of their characters to justify their actions. In that location'south that strong concept of time obsession throughout the movie... symbolized by the appearance of watches, the extra four months of life, the consistent questionable issues on when the rebellion would occur, the time it takes for the scream to dice down in the torture chambers, etc., etc.
The very stark soundtracks, used for a lot of the scenes, are every bit horrifying every bit the sights of the crematoria... at times too unbearable to heed! Yep, everything is so bleakly dark throughout with scenes, from frame to frame, leaving me common cold. The dialogue works very well here, not assuasive any lengthy glib to distract the audition from the gruesome takes and deportment. And what provides me with even more stifling uneasiness is the film's honest revelation that practiced men can lose their self dignity and humanity to save their own skins, subjecting themselves to participate in incredibly awful acts of cruelty.
I'k however finding it too depressing to imagine that anyone, faced with death, could even asked what `you'll practise for a little more life!' Should one volunteer in the most unimaginable heinous acts, only for a few months of life? I was obviously numbed by the contents of this film. Whoa, what a gripping and astonishing business relationship of those who had really helped gas their own brethren! Information technology's definitely also powerful for anyone who just can't tummy whatsoever graphic atrocities... this film has an affluence of them! Just watching the heaps and heaps of naked bodies stacking up is so totally nauseous. The scenes with Mira Sorvino and Natasha Lyonne's characters are truthfully too hard for me to handle.
Is this movie worth the price of a regular tix? Yep, if there's a good lesson to be learned. Hatred and selfishness encourage atrocious acts and should have no living space in our society.
My rating for this moving-picture show: A
1 out of ii found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0252480/reviews
0 Response to "what technique does wiesel use to build tension on the approach to the auschwitz crematoriums?"
Post a Comment